Air Fryer New York Strip Steak

This Air Fryer New York Strip is tender and scrumptious with numerous taste – even and not using a grill! Better of all it’s extremely straightforward to make with out inflicting a multitude within the kitchen. Topped with an elective chive butter, this complete meal cooks in lower than Quarter-hour.

If you have not tried New York strip within the air fryer, you are really lacking out on a very simple recipe that you need to use on weeknights. With my timing and temperature suggestions, the steak is cooked completely to your liking.

Pair this air fryer NY strip with a easy Butter Lettuce Salad and my Boursin Mashed Potatoes for a scrumptious meal!

New york strip steak on a cutting board with a knife and rosemary.

Why Make New York Strip in an Air Fryer?

I like an awesome grilled steak, however as soon as I had two younger youngsters, my mindset about my previous cooking methods modified. Typically you actually simply need an awesome steak that is quick and straightforward, and would not require heating up a grill or making an enormous splattering mess in a forged iron pan.

In truth I used to be so shocked that my air fryer flank steak turned out so good, I wished to check it with different varieties of steak. You will love this air fryer New York Strip as a result of:

Simple – Minimal substances, straightforward clear up, and no oiling grill grates or coping with splatter screens!
Quick – Prepared in simply Quarter-hour.
No grill, no drawback – If you happen to do not personal or have entry to a grill, it is a nice steak recipe!

This recipe suits a gluten free, dairy free (with out the compound butter), low sodium, low histamine, and migraine food plan!

Soar to:

What Air Fryer Is Finest?

For recipe testing, I used the Cosori Air Fryer Professional (5 qt) and the Cosori Twin Blaze (6 qt) to do that out in many various methods. You may get a reduction on all Cosori merchandise with the code THEDIZZYCOOK20.

You probably have a smaller household or personal an prompt pot, I’ve made steak with my air fryer lid earlier than and likewise discover it will get a pleasant sear on the highest.

Typically with the toaster oven mixture air fryers, I discover they won’t produce the identical sear outcomes. On this case, you could need to pre-sear the steaks in a forged iron pan, however I do know that defeats the aim! Simply is determined by how essential to you that caramelization is.

Substances

Ingredients for air fryer New York strip steak with chive compound butter.

New York Strip Steak – That is personally my favourite lower of steak. From a young a part of the quick loin, it is an awesome lower for each texture and taste. It might even be generally known as strip steak or Kansas Metropolis strip steak. USDA prime is usually the most effective, however USDA selection or grass-fed are additionally good choices. Typically I discover grass fed is a little bit bit much less marbled with fats, however the butter helps! Steak must be about ¾”-1″ thickness. If it’s extremely thick, you possibly can slice them in half.
Avocado oil – Due to the upper warmth degree, I prefer to brush these with avocado oil, however ghee (clarified butter) can be used.
Salt – More often than not salt is an afterthought, however since this recipe is so easy, a superb high quality kosher salt could make a giant distinction. A whole lot of cooks will use Diamond Kosher Salt which has mild, hallow flakes. This implies it is much less salty and extra crumbly than different varieties of kosher salt like Morton’s, which is extra dense. I like utilizing Diamond for meat seasonings the place there’s not so much happening as you possibly can add extra seasoning with out overpowering the meal.
Recent black pepper – Use freshly cracked black pepper as an alternative of pre-ground. This will even add extra taste and a little bit little bit of texture to the steak.

Chive compound butter is elective, however can present a burst of additional taste for a special day. I take advantage of good high quality butter like Kerrygold, garlic, contemporary chives, and rosemary.

The right way to Air Fry New York Strip Steak

Four process photos showing how to cook a NY strip steak in the air fryer.

Step 1: Season the steaks

Though I personally like to drag my steaks out of the fridge about 10-Quarter-hour earlier than cooking, it is a fable they should come to room temperature. Pat steaks as dry as doable. Brush the steaks flippantly with avocado oil and season generously with kosher salt and black pepper on either side. (Footage 1, 2)

Step 2: Air fry

Preheat the air fryer to 420 levels Fahrenheit. Add the NY strip to the air fryer basket crisper plate and air fry for about 7 minutes. Flip and prepare dinner one other 3-5 minutes relying on desired doneness. (Footage 3, 4)

In case your air fryer doesn’t attain 420 levels Fahrenheit, don’t be concerned! You may prepare dinner these at 400 levels for nearer to eight minutes, then flip and prepare dinner one other 4-6 minutes.

Air Frying with the Cosori Twin Blaze

Pat the steak dry and season with kosher salt and black pepper on either side. Place the steak straight onto the underside of the air fryer basket with out the crisper plate.

I used the “steak” setting however discovered my NY strip steak (about 1″ thickness) was executed to an ideal medium on the 8 minute level, though their directions mentioned to prepare dinner for one more 4 minutes.

I discovered that cooking on the steak operate for six minutes, including the compound butter

Cooked NY strip steak sliced and topped with flakes of sea salt and rosemary.

Step 3: Relaxation and Slice

If utilizing the compound butter, unfold on high of the steaks whereas heat. Enable them to relaxation at the very least minutes earlier than slicing.

Chive Garlic Compound Butter

A compound butter like this chive garlic butter elevates the flavour just like you’ll have when searing the NY strip in a forged iron pan and spooning the butter over the meat.

It’ll retailer nicely within the fridge for as much as 2 weeks or within the freezer for 3-6 months. I add it to baked bread, eggs, and shellfish dishes.

Four process shots showing how to make a chive garlic compound butter and roll it into a log for storage.

NY Strip Air Fryer Cooking Instances

These had been the instances I discovered labored finest in testing with my basket air fryer and 1″ thick New York strip steak. Bear in mind this can be completely different for combo air fryers.

10 minutes for medium uncommon – 130-135F inside temperature.
11-12 minutes for medium – 140-145F inside temperature.
13 minutes for medium nicely – about 150F inside temperature.

In case your steak is bigger, you could want extra time on either side. I might add a minute on either side, checking the inner temperature on the midway level.

A sliced steak showing a well done interior. — This steak was executed to medium-well temperature.

Knowledgeable Ideas for the Excellent Steak

High quality cuts – With such a easy recipe, selecting a superb lower could make a distinction with taste. However since USDA prime is so good, however costly, I have a tendency to avoid wasting that for after I sear or grill steaks, and use grass-fed or selection for my air fryer nights. It is fully as much as you and what you are searching for!
Spend money on a superb meat thermometer like ThermoWorks for an correct temperature studying. This will even assist to keep away from overcooking.
The steak inside temperature can improve because it rests, so hold that in thoughts when you’re a pair levels under the place you want to the steak to be. This may be wherever from 3-5 levels.

A plate with a fork and knife next to a cooked strip steak that's topped with chives.

Aspect Dishes

This New York strip steak within the air fryer pairs nicely with many various facet dishes. Listed below are just a few of my favorites.

Incessantly Requested Questions

Do air fryers prepare dinner steaks nicely?

I feel you would be shocked at how nicely air fryers prepare dinner steaks. I used to be shocked at how completely cooked flank steaks had been that I began attempting different cuts. Not solely is it quick with straightforward clear up, however it’s additionally simpler to get your required inside temperature than a grill.

How I can I make sure to not overcook the steaks?

My finest recommendation is to put money into a superb meat thermometer like ThermoWorks, then use the information in my directions in your desired inside temperature. Do not forget that the inner temperature of the steak can improve a pair levels as you relaxation the steaks.

Do I want a compound butter for steaks?

Not at all times! I normally do not add butter to steaks if cooking on the grill. Nevertheless, I feel it really works nicely with air fryer steaks, just like searing in a forged iron. It offers a lift of taste.

A strip steak with butter on a cutting board with a knife and blue and white napkin.

Air Fryer Recipes

For extra recipes like these air fryer NY strip steaks, see these posts. And do not miss my air fryer flank steak.

If you happen to make this, tag me #thedizzycook or @thedizzycook on Fb and Instagram. And when you love the recipe, please depart a overview under! Comply with alongside on my Pinterest for extra nice recipes.